This photo was made during my recent trip to Rock Creek-Little Lakes Valley with Michael, Dan, and Steve Cole. The others had wandered off to Bishop to visit Mountain Light and Vern Clevenger's gallery, so I decided to hop up to the meadows just below Rock Creek Lake.
Tachihara 4x5
Nikkor 300mm
Astia 100F
No Filter
I tried out the sharpening technique that Marc Adums uses, so I am very interested in how you perceive the sharpness of this photograph.
Thanks, everyone,
-PB
Posted by Lars Jensen on August 18, 2006 at 5:05 PM
The foilage, which is always susceptible to oversharpening, does look very pixelated, and even noisy, to me. Makes it kind of look like a painting or something. Very beautiful shot though.
I used Neat Image to remove the noise. I then made a selection of just the stream and rocks and used USM to sharpen that section independently. I think it looks much better. You can see the results here: ReWorked Image
Your thought are always appreciated.
-PB
Posted by Cory Freeman on August 19, 2006 at 4:11 PM
I think the second one did the trick! Nice image Preston!
Richard-Vern moved his gallery to N. Main St. I haven't been inside but drove by a few weeks ago. If I recall it's just before the fairgrounds, Next to the new Starbucks.
Thanks for the comment! I have a terrible time with sharpening! Maybe I need to update my eyeglasses prescription!
It was great to see you at Rock Creek! The boyz and I definitely had a great time!
I hope you can join me (us) at Bishop Creek for the CANP gathering!
-PB
Posted by John W. Wall on August 20, 2006 at 11:25 AM
I'm a terrible judge of sharpening, too, and I can't tell if it looks oversharpened (the revised one, that is) or if I'm just seeing/imagining more detail than usual because of the large format of the original. I like the shot, though, and it lends weight to my thought that 4x5 is really a separate art form. I mean, the same picture taken in 35mm wouldn't be as interesting. There's something beautiful about capturing so much detail in a relatively ordinary scene. Hope this makes sense!
Posted by Reno DiTullio on August 21, 2006 at 11:15 PM
Preston, I like the reworked image much better, very crisp detail without signs of over sharpening, well done.
Discussion
10 repliesTachihara 4x5
Nikkor 300mm
Astia 100F
No Filter
I tried out the sharpening technique that Marc Adums uses, so I am very interested in how you perceive the sharpness of this photograph.
Thanks, everyone,
-PB
I think I'll go back and play with it some more. My old eyes just aren't the same anymore for really fine detail.
Regards,
Preston
i like the little patch of blurred water rapid in the foreground.
I used Neat Image to remove the noise. I then made a selection of just the stream and rocks and used USM to sharpen that section independently. I think it looks much better. You can see the results here: ReWorked Image
Your thought are always appreciated.
-PB
Richard-Vern moved his gallery to N. Main St. I haven't been inside but drove by a few weeks ago. If I recall it's just before the fairgrounds, Next to the new Starbucks.
Thanks for the comment! I have a terrible time with sharpening! Maybe I need to update my eyeglasses prescription!
It was great to see you at Rock Creek! The boyz and I definitely had a great time!
I hope you can join me (us) at Bishop Creek for the CANP gathering!
-PB
The original image is just a tad oversharpened. I like it.
BTW, how does Marc Adamus sharpen?
I posted the technique that Marc uses, here on CANP. I hope it helps you.
-PB