American tree sparrow

Nice job on this one John.  Nice and sharp and good exposure.  Looks a little tight in the frame.  I wonder if a horizontal orientation might work, giving the bird some space to look in to / a little more space on the right.

Nice shot, John.
I agree with Jim about some more room on the picture.
Also, I think I can see some marks of your cloning tasks, in two areas: right below bird tail, and in the bottom of the picture, under the perch.

John: a well exposed and detailed shot of the bird, but just a bit too tightly framed. I can see a few spots to the left and below the bird where you missed with the cloning. Easily fixed. Richard

Excellent detail and the exposure looks spot on, John.  I'm seeing the cloning artifacts that Jefferson mentioned and I also agree that it's a bit tight.  Hard to resist when you have the glass to get close.

Hi John, agree with others about the room and cloning artifacts. Both easy fixes. If this was not a crop, should be easy to add more canvas to this one. If crop, easy to add back space. I like everything else about it.