Sandstone Monochrome+Repost

I think your color work is outstanding, but it is interesting to see this relying on textures alone. I think it looks great as is. The contrast between dark and light looks perfect.

The tones in this look very good overall Tony. It looks just a little bit flat and I would boost the contrast a little bit if it were mine. That would give it a more 3 dimensional look I think. Interesting to see something in monochrome from you!

Wonderful patterns and textures... almost resembles animal skin. The folds and layers of rock make this one a stand out as a rock abstract. Great choice for a b&w and love the subtle warm toning.

Hi Tony,
This composition is stunning. I agree that more contrast may help. I am wondering what it might look like if you were to paint some streaks of color back in. Maybe just a few of the more pale, narrow bands? It might be very intriguing.

I agree with Joseph's comments about contrast. Personally I'd add a little, but it's great as posted and what a wonderful composition.

Bumped up the contrast a bit in this version per Joe's suggeston. I think I like it better. Feels more abstract, which I like.

Very nice Tony. The patterns and lines are wonderful! Most of all I love the textured feel and warm tone. I like the repost with a little more contrast as Joe suggested.

Nick Bristol
Lone Rock, WI

Really fine abstract, Tony. Out of the norm for you, but it is great seeing you step outside your normal zone. Besides, it gives you a lot more shooting opportunities where the colors are not all that spectacular. I am very much liking the repost, too.

I prefer the repost as well. The amazing thing is that even without color just by seeing the thumbnail I immediately recognized this as one of yours - you truly have a vision and style of your own (and I mean that in a good way)!

Heresy!
I like the increased contrast. But, then again, I usually do.

The repost is really nice. Great abstract.

- Dan

I kind of prefer the original, but it's a close call. Wild patterns--pretty cool!

I like the patterns and textures in both versions, which stand out nicely in monochrome. Perhaps I slightly prefer the original to the repost overall.

A great example of nature's patterns and taffy-flow made more visible in b/w. I like the comp...and the add'l contrast of the repost. Another couple thoughts (1) to boost 3-d more by accenting the areas where light is shaded to darken more...such as that fold in bottom third. Then to brighten the the ridge tops where light is stronger... The second thought is this size which does not allow me to enjoy the surface texture as much as I would like. A large version is always pleasing. On the whole this is terrific.

I really like the textures in this shot, and nice comp. I like both, but probably prefer the first shot with less contrast.

Tony,

I think you're on to something. Never crossed my mind that your sandstone images would work in b&w. This one most certainly does! The graphic nature, lines and patterns are showcased beautifully. AND your processing mastery shines as well. I think I prefer the more subdued original, but the luminosity in the repost is quite appealing as well.

Nice to see an image from you and great job trying something new.

Lon

Wonderful Image Tony, wow there is alot going on here as a abstract. I like the 2nd verion. Your composition and the patterns are amazing. Excellent work!

I love this Tony. Wonderful patterns and a broad range of tones. I think I prefer your original since there is more detail in the lighter area in the upper right. Outstanding work!

I'm digging the lines! Great B&W, i prefer the original, there seems to be more detail.

I like them both, but my preference is for the original. the more subtle contrasts are quite appealing to me. the b&w is an excellent presentation.

Great abstract work. The monochrone works well here. I'd prefer the second version (repost) though the first one was already great. Great patterns and texture. Love this a lot.

Both are good, but I like the increased contrast in the second better. It has a great feel of unending continuance beyond the frame.

Wonderful abstract feeling to this Tony. While the original is good, the added contrast in the repost set it apart. I'd love to have it in my portfolio.

Phenomenal photograph Tony. Even without color your compositions just rivet the viewer.

This looks great Tony, love all the textures. I particularly like the lines in the lower 1/3.

Gary.

This is just so fantastic , love the processing it really suits those lines and contours !

Tony, there is an interesting flow in your composition that really keeps my attention within the frame. I enjoy exploring the diversity of the pattern. The repost with enhanced contrast works even better for me.

Peter

Wow! Amazing how this works in B&W also. I think I prefer the original post, or maybe between. Or both :-).