The Struggle
by Luke Ormand
Yesterday a juvenile Humpback Whale beached itself at the famous Main Beach in East Hampton Village. It is quite rare for a live whale to come ashore on Long Island and as such it has created quite the draw. The marine mammal rescue people (Riverhead Foundation) have determined it is likely too sick to survive, and it is not worth the risk to volunteers to push the whale back into the ocean - they are currently (after 2 days) trying to determine how to properly euthanize the whale. It is a sad sight, but it's also nature. Whales have been beaching themselves when sick for tens of thousands (much more I presume) of years and many believe since it's here we should try to push it back and save it.
What upsets me about the situation is not that it can't be "saved" (again, it's sick and it's nature, sad, but true). But that once it has perished, it will be dragged ashore and buried (after a necropsy). It would be preferable to me if it could be dragged out to sea for the fish and birds to consume - but there are "liability" issues with something like that.
The Whale moved its tail up and opened its mouth twice in a minute, each lasting a few brief seconds and I was able to capture both instances (I missed a few shots because I was zoomed in too close) and it was unbelievable to see this giant beast struggle so.
I took several hundred shots and have toyed with making some B&W and will post a variety of photos in the fauna gallery based on the comments and critiques I receive. I also will post other shots that won't make it to NPN on my blog in the future.
Nikon D300s 18-200mm VR @ 170 HH from rock jetty.
f/13
1/800s
ISO 500
Cropped to approximately 65%, Straightened horizon, sharpened whale, noise reduction on sky, increased saturation on blacks.
I must give an assist to Sandy Richards who sold me this lens and got it to me on time! Without this lens, I would have been hamstrung with my 300 or my 105 macro. This was my first time trying the lens out and the results were fantastic!
Comments
31 commentshttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_t44siFyb4
Great photo, Luke. Very compelling.
Ys, it's "nature" but humans have a responsibility to be stewards of nature and the fellow inhabitants and critters of this planet.
Rest in peace.
Sandy r
Congratulation
Mauro
Interesting shot and compelling story. I hope you keep us updated with more images. It would be my hope that they (whoever they are?) leave bad enough alone and let nature take its course where it lies, feeding birds, fish and other scavengers. If there are other scavangers on Long Island.
Neil
An exceptionally unique and compelling image. The drama (and your very interesting commentary) make it easy to forget how well you did here as a photographer - your timing was excellent and you did well in a situation where it would be have been easy to blow the exposure (literally) - well done.
My preference in these situations is to simply let nature take its course. I'd prefer to channel efforts on stopping things like the "scientific whaling" that some nations engage in, the results of which end up in restaurants of a certain country.
Thanks for sharing this Luke - looking forward to seeing more!
Cheers...
Brad
Thank you for the comments and I agree wholly on letting nature run its course. Whales have been beaching themselves when sick as long as they've existed as a species, and just becuase humans now witness this doens't mean we should intefere. As for handling the situation, I have to thank you for recent comments on my seal photos about DOF which stuck in my mind and reminded me to have the appropriate f/stop for good DOF which I think worked perfectly here.
Everyone else, thanks for the comments. In my next post I will either post links to articles or summaries of articles on my blog so all the pertinent information can be read at once in a concise manner.
An attempt to euthanize the whale was undertaken last night (1 AM and again at 2 AM) with giant darts (which look like arrows) and has been unsuccessful. I'm happy I was there yesterday and not today where the poor whale as 2 giant arrows sticking out of it. Apparently veterinary specialists around the country are being consulted on how to move forward.
- Luke
cheers,Luca
Outstanding job and great story! Your timing is impeccable and the composition is excellent. Thanks for sharing this with us and for the background story. Cheers!
as for the shot, it's quite impressive. you did very well with the DOF and exposure. I think that comp-wise, I'd prefer to see the whale a little more to the lower left. very cool shot, Luke.
Ken Archer
I can imagine the story by your wonderful shot. Also if it's nature it's always sad when I see a whale beached.
THIS IS BECAUSE WE DONT REALLY UNDERSTAND NATURE
WE THINK WE DO- AND MAYBE WE DO A LITTLE ??
BUT WE HAVE TO MANY FEELINGS AND THINK THEY NEED HELP.
If an animal is injured that is another thing we can help but this is its natural way of doing things .
SO LET IT BE
Congrats on the EP.
D&L
Glad to have had a tiny role in it - but the skill was all yours!
Sandy r
Congrats on your EP.
wonderful image but you should not be posting images like that :-(. It is even worse for me than watch people dying and I could not have image like that in my portfolio or anywhere. But once again the photo itself is great.
Regards....
Jagdeep Rajput